December 21, 2011

Pennsylvania Legislators Shoot Down Pigeons - Again

... by Walter Brasch

If the first year gross anatomy class at the Penn State Hershey medical school needs spare body parts to study, they can visit the cloak room of the Pennsylvania House of Representatives. That's where most of the legislators left their spines.

The House voted 124–69, Dec. 13, to send an animal welfare bill back to committee, in this case the Gaming Oversight Committee. The bill, SB 71, would have banned simulcasting of greyhound races from other states. Pennsylvania had banned greyhound racing in 2004. Among several of the current bill's amendments were ones that would also have banned the sale of cat and dog meat, increased penalties for releasing exotic animals, and stopped the cruelty of live pigeon shoots.

It's the pigeon shoot amendment, sponsored by Rep. John Maher (R-Allegheny), that caused legislators to hide beneath their desks, apparently in fear of the poop from the NRA, which lobbied extensively against ending pigeon shoots. The unrelenting NRA message irrationally claimed that banning pigeon shoots is the first step to banning guns. The NRA even called the Humane Society of the United States (HSUS) a radical animal rights group. The House action leaves Pennsylvania as the only state where pretend hunters, most of them from New Jersey and surrounding states where pigeon shoots are illegal, to come to Pennsylvania and kill caged birds launched in front of spectators and the shooters.

Most pigeon shoots are held in Berks County in southeastern Pennsylvania, with one in the nearby suburban Philadelphia area. Scared and undernourished birds are placed into small cages, and then released about 20 yards in front of people with 12-gauge shotguns. Most birds, as many as 5,000 at an all-day shoot, are hit standing on their cages, on the ground, or flying erratically just a few feet from the people who pretend to be sportsmen. Even standing only feet from their kill, the shooters aren’t as good as they think they are. About 70 percent of all birds are wounded, according to Heidi Prescott, HSUS senior vice-president, who for about 25 years has been documenting and leading the effort to pass legislation to finally end pigeon shoots in the state.

Birds that fall outside the shooting club's property are left to die long and horrible deaths. If the birds are wounded on the killing fields, trapper boys and girls, most in their early teens, some of them younger, grab the birds, wring their necks, stomp on their bodies, or throw them live into barrels to suffocate. There is no food or commercial value of a pigeon killed at one of the shoots.

The lure of pigeon shoots, in addition to what the participants must think is a wanton sense of fulfillment, is gambling, illegal under Pennsylvania law but not enforced by the Pennsylvania State Police.

The International Olympic Committee banned the so-called sport after the 1900 Olympics because of its cruelty to animals. Most hunters, as well as the Pennsylvania Game Commission, say that pigeon shoots aren't "fair chase hunting." Almost every daily newspaper in the state and dozens of organizations, from the Council of Churches to the Pennsylvania Bar Association, oppose this form of animal cruelty.

On the floor of the House, Rep. Rosita C. Youngblood (D-Philadelphia), usually a supporter of animal rights issues, spoke out against voting on the bill, and asked other Democrats to go along with her. Youngblood is minority chair of the Gaming Oversight committee.

Youngblood's chief of staff, Bill Thomas, emphasizes that Youngblood's only concern was to protect the integrity of the legislative process. Although some members truly believed they voted to recommit the bill for procedural reasons, most members were just simply afraid to vote on the bill. Voting to recommit the bill were 52 Democrats, many of them opposed to pigeon shoots; 35 voted to keep it on the floor for debate. Among Republicans, the vote was 72–34 to send the bill to committee.

The Arguments

Germaneness: The Republican leadership had determined that all amendments to bills in the current legislative session must be germane to the bill. "You can't hijack a bill," many in the House, including key Democrats, claimed as the major reason they voted against SB71.

However, the Republicans, with a majority in the House and able to block any bill in committee that didn't meet their strict political agenda, raised "germaneness" to a level never before seen in the House. For decades, Democrats and Republicans attached completely unrelated amendments to bills. Even during this session, the Republicans, in violation of their own "rules," attached amendments to allow school vouchers onto several bills, many that had nothing to do with education. But, the Greyhound racing bill was considered under both gambling and animal cruelty concerns. Thus, the amendment to ban pigeon shoots could also be considered to be an animal cruelty amendment and not subject to the Judiciary Committee, where it was likely to die.

Separate bill. Several legislators believed the attempt to stop pigeon shoots should have been its own bill, not tacked onto another bill.

However, only twice have bills about pigeon shoots come to the floor of the House. Most proposed legislation had been buried in committees or blocked by House leadership, both Democrat and Republican, most of whom received support and funding from the NRA, gun owner groups, and their political action committees (PACs). In 1989, the Pennsylvania House had defeated a bill to ban pigeon shoots, 66–126. By 1994, three years after the first large scale protest, the House voted 99–93 in favor of an amendment to ban pigeon shoots, but fell short of the 102 votes needed for passage.

The bill would duplicate or repeal a recently-signed law:
Rep. Curt Schroeder (R-Chester Co.), chair of the Gaming Oversight committee, sponsored the House version of the Senate's bill. If it was truly an unnecessary bill, he or the leadership could have previously sent it to committee for reworking or killed it. According to sources close to the leadership, despite his concern for animal welfare, Schroeder was not pleased about the amendments tacked onto his bill.

Short time to accomplish much: Several Democrats believed that by spending extraordinary time on the bill, necessary legislation would not be brought to the floor and the Republicans could then blame the Democrats for blocking key legislation.

However, both parties already knew how they would vote for redistricting (the Republicans had gerrymandered the state to protect certain districts), school vouchers, and other proposed legislation. Further, the Republican leadership could have blocked putting the Greyhound bill into the agenda or placed it at the end of other bills. Even on the floor of the House, the leadership could have shut down debate at any time. Thus, the Democrats' argument about "only four days left" is blunted by the Republicans' own actions. During 2011, the House met only 54 days when the vote on SB 71 was taken. If the House was so concerned about having only four days left in the year to discuss and vote upon critical issues, it could have added days to the work week or increased hours while in session. Speaker Mike Turzai (R-Allegheny), to his credit, wanted a vote, although he personally opposed the pigeon shoot amendment. "Let's put this issue to rest," he told the members. Taking the time to debate the bill, says Bill Thomas, "wasted taxpayer money and time." However, "the amount of time spent avoiding the bill," counters Prescott, "wastes far more time and resources than voting on it."

Nevertheless, no matter what the arguments, sending the bill to committee was a good way to avoid having to deal with a highly controversial issue. It allowed many legislators to pretend to their constituents that they still believe in animal welfare, while avoiding getting blow-back from the NRA or its supporters. Conversely, it allowed many of those who wanted to keep pigeon shoots to avoid a debate and subsequent vote, allowing continued support from pro-gun constituents who accept the NRA non-logic, while not offending constituents who believe in animal welfare.

Whatever their reasons, the failure of the many of the state's representatives to stand up for their convictions probably caused legislation to ban this form of animal cruelty to be as dead during this session as the pigeons whose necks are wrung by teenagers who finish the kill by people who think they're sportsmen but are little more than juveniles disguised in the bodies of adults.

[Walter Brasch is an award-winning syndicated social issues columnist, former newspaper and magazine reporter and editor, whose specialties included public affairs/investigative reporting. He is professor emeritus of journalism. Dr. Brasch's latest novel is Before the First Snow, a story of the counterculture and set in rural Pennsylvania.]

Posted by Walter Brasch at December 21, 2011 11:19 AM | Miscellaneous | Technorati links |


discussion is there is a vast gathering of individuals comprising of researchers, tree huggers, and other people who have demonstrated strong confirmation that human activity like assignment help companies , particularly carbon outflows, have caused an awkwardness in the normal atmosphere cycles of the earth.

Posted by: Alice Brampton at May 8, 2018 12:31 AM

The state's oversight responsibility over the education agents is outsourced to the American private schools providing the courses. According to
vital for academic success
Außergewöhnliches solarrekord

Posted by: Elisha Morris at June 25, 2018 12:12 AM

Great tips and very easy to understand. This will definitely be very useful for me when I get a chance to start my blog. Red Grapes

Posted by: sheeraz khatri at July 8, 2018 09:50 AM

As a seller of legal steroids, you can buy Crazy Bulk products, explore stacks and finally get the body you’ve always wanted Hero Instinct

Posted by: sheeraz khatri at July 10, 2018 11:37 PM

I see some amazingly important and kept up to length of your strength searching for in your on the site Language of Desire

Posted by: sheeraz khatri at July 11, 2018 01:02 AM

Really appreciate this wonderful post that you have provided for us.Great site and a great topic as well i really get amazed to read this. Its really good. Honey

Posted by: sheeraz khatri at July 11, 2018 02:19 AM

I liked your article and I hope you will have many entries or more Love Commands

Posted by: sheeraz khatri at July 11, 2018 06:40 AM

I was very pleased to find this site.I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post. Obsession Phrases

Posted by: sheeraz khatri at July 11, 2018 08:34 AM

A good blog always comes-up with new and exciting information and while reading I have feel that this blog is really have all those quality that qualify a blog to be a one. Revive Her Drive

Posted by: sheeraz khatri at July 11, 2018 09:50 AM

I am overwhelmed by your post with such a nice topic. Usually I visit your blogs and get updated through the information you include but today’s blog would be the most appreciable. Well done! What Men Secretly Want

Posted by: sheeraz khatri at July 11, 2018 10:14 AM

I will really appreciate the writer's choice for choosing this excellent article appropriate to my matter.Here is deep description about the article matter which helped me more. Lovetraction Lines

Posted by: sheeraz khatri at July 11, 2018 11:39 PM

Writing with style and getting good compliments on the article is quite hard, to be honest.But you've done it so calmly and with so cool feeling and you've nailed the job. This article is possessed with style and I am giving good compliment. Best! Make Him Desire You

Posted by: sheeraz khatri at July 12, 2018 03:25 AM

The worst part of it was that the software only worked intermittently and the data was not accurate. You obviously canot confront anyone about what you have discovered if the information is not right. Save The Marriage System

Posted by: sheeraz khatri at July 12, 2018 04:59 AM

Thanks for your article! I have read through some similar topics free gift codes generator

Posted by: maitrishah at July 19, 2018 07:37 AM

Thanks for writing such a good article, I stumbled onto your blog and read a few post. I like your style of writing. saeco coffee machines

Posted by: Julia Martin at July 20, 2018 12:27 AM

This is a disgrace to all defenders of human rights. Affordable Lawyers

Posted by: Henry Walters at August 14, 2018 04:52 AM

Since you were doing great, you have to endeavor to make sense of what you changed that made your scores tumble off. Make sense of what you're doing any other way and you ought to improve the situation. explainer video pricing. Have an accomplished shooter watch you check whether they see anything.

Posted by: Brenna Neil at August 15, 2018 12:58 AM

Yotta Games, Mafia City H5, Genuine underworld strategy html5 game, play with millions of players worldwide. Worldwide connection,no color, language or nationality differences and together compete to become the Godfather.

Posted by: Yifan Xie at August 26, 2018 08:26 PM

In the wake of perusing your article I was stunned. I realize that you clarify it exceptionally well. What's more, I trust that different perusers will likewise encounter how I feel in the wake of perusing your article. Furniture Store Financing

Posted by: pioneerseo at October 16, 2018 02:05 AM

I wear t have room schedule-wise right now to completely read your site yet I have bookmarked it and furthermore include your RSS channels. I will return in a day or two. much obliged for an extraordinary site. Mattress Store Financing

Posted by: pioneerseo at October 16, 2018 03:03 AM

Gangaur Realtech is a professionally directed association work in arrive associations where solidified associations are given by authorities to its customers hunting down expanded a spark by owning, having or putting resources into arrive. Auto Repair Financing

Posted by: pioneerseo at October 16, 2018 03:52 AM

You may remark on the request design of the blog. You should visit it's brain boggling. Your blog review would swell up your guests. I was to an awesome degree satisfied to discover this site.I anticipated that would thank you for this impossible read!! Pet Store Financing

Posted by: pioneerseo at October 16, 2018 05:21 AM

To a great degree wonderful and entrancing post. I was hunting down this kind of information and had a great time examining this one. Pet Financing

Posted by: pioneerseo at October 16, 2018 06:04 AM

In the wake of perusing your article I was stunned. I realize that you clarify it exceptionally well. What's more, I trust that different perusers will likewise encounter how I feel in the wake of perusing your article. gifts for husband

Posted by: pioneerseo at October 16, 2018 09:17 PM

This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information... blank dvd printing

Posted by: sheeraz khatri at October 18, 2018 02:57 AM

With so many books and articles coming up to give gateway to make-money-online field and confusing reader even more on the actual way of earning money, Composite Doors 2 You Wales

Posted by: sheeraz khatri at October 18, 2018 07:18 AM

Such an exceptionally valuable article. Extremely intriguing to peruse this article.I might want to thank you for the endeavors you had made for composing this amazing article. fiberglass attic insulation

Posted by: pioneerseo at October 18, 2018 09:07 PM

To start with You got an awesome blog .I will be keen on more comparative points. I see you got extremely exceptionally valuable themes, I will be continually checking your blog much appreciated. prestamos credito

Posted by: pioneerseo at October 19, 2018 12:34 AM

Business information site. business information

Posted by: pioneerseo at October 19, 2018 02:29 AM

A blog about small and medium businesses. business blog

Posted by: pioneerseo at October 19, 2018 04:22 AM

My Essay Writer is the go-to source for the completion of academic assignments. If you are screaming out “essay writing service,” you’ve come to the most elite essay writing service

Posted by: sheeraz khatri at October 23, 2018 04:41 AM

This is a splendid website! I"m extremely content with the remarks!.

Posted by: sheeraz khatri at October 24, 2018 01:37 AM

Thanx for sharing such useful post keep it up :) kasyno

Posted by: sheeraz khatri at October 24, 2018 04:40 AM

Play all your favorite Casino Games, Poker, Slot Game, Football & Sports Betting with Online Casino Malaysia ! Visit 88GASIA Today. casino online malaysia

Posted by: pioneerseo at November 24, 2018 07:19 AM

Extremely decent blog and articles. I am realy extremely glad to visit your blog. Presently I am discovered which I really need. I check your blog regular and attempt to take in something from your blog. Much obliged to you and sitting tight for your new post. affordable web design

Posted by: pioneerseo at November 24, 2018 08:28 PM

Do you want to discover your future thanks to a complete voyance par téléphone ? Do you want to know what will happen in your life for love, work, family and dreams ? So you can go to this website of divinatory arts and esoterism. It will allows you to read a lot for free and no subscription.You can also contact a fortune teller by a direct call to 0892 22 20 22 ; and take the benefit of a true voyance téléphone ; quality and complete predictions. voyance par téléphone

Posted by: pioneerseo at November 25, 2018 08:43 PM

Best content you write there. Use such an amazing 99 rs domain godaddy 

Posted by: Eliana Toorkey at November 25, 2018 11:18 PM

Best Spell Caster Sanchit Aggarwal Ji.Get Solution of all Problem easily by Powerful Spells. love spells

Posted by: pioneerseo at November 26, 2018 10:32 PM

Digital Daddy offers a range of website packages to suit any business budget.The best part? All our website packages offer unbeatable value. Website Packages

Posted by: pioneerseo at November 26, 2018 11:21 PM

Exceptionally useful post ! There is a considerable measure of data here that can enable any business to begin with a fruitful long range informal communication campaign ! singapore female boudoir

Posted by: pioneerseo at November 29, 2018 09:43 PM

It's time to discover your future thanks to a voyance par téléphone available to 0892 22 20 33. This is a voyance discount service which guarantee quality and empathy. Fortune-telling is a passion and an art. There is many ways to predict the future : cristall ball, tarot cards, pendulum... and even nothing but pure talent. Voyance par tel ; our team is always here to help voyance discount

Posted by: pioneerseo at November 30, 2018 08:46 PM

Jumpapoker agen judi poker online terpercaya dan bandar ceme terbaik indonesia yang memberikan bonus poker terbesar, bandar judi online resmi uang asli rupiah, TANPA BOT poker terpercaya

Posted by: pioneerseo at November 30, 2018 09:04 PM

Birds that relapse outside the shooting club's property are left to die long and dismal deaths...such a compelling to read this 1 Dollar Domain Name Registration I would love to recommend you a link where you can build your own website and can share your writing skills

Posted by: Denny Parker at December 5, 2018 09:18 PM
Post a comment

Remember personal info?

You must preview your comment first before posting.