June 02, 2008

The Politics of Humanitarian Aid

... by Walter Brasch

President Bush was justifiably upset. A cyclone four days earlier had destroyed a large portion of Myanmar, and the country's military junta was still refusing humanitarian aid. "Let the United States come to help you, help the people," Bush pleaded with the junta. "We're prepared to move U.S. Navy assets to help find those who've lost their lives, to help find the missing, to help stabilize the situation," said the President, "but in order to do so, the military junta must allow our disaster assessment teams into the country."

With more than 20,000 dead, possibly 40,000 missing, and close to one million homeless, the junta made it clear that it, not the international community, would provide whatever humanitarian aid was necessary.

A week before the cyclone hit, President Bush extended sanctions against Myanmar by another year because of what he called that junta's "large-scale repression of the democratic opposition." Paranoid about anything that could threaten its power, the junta was frightened that the United States would use the cyclone as a reason to invade the country.

The junta's response the first week of May was little different than the international concern almost three years earlier. It wasn't the destruction of villages and the rice farming industry, but the destruction of cities and the shrimp industry. It wasn't a cyclone named Nargis, but a hurricane named Katrina.

It's been well documented that the Bush–Cheney Administration, with its head in Iraq, wasn't prepared for a natural disaster. Like the leaders in Myanmar, the Bush–Cheney Administration was slow to inform the people, and slow to act during the crisis. Less known is that President Bush refused innumerable offers of assistance to the people of the Gulf Coast.

More than 20 countries—including Israel, Mexico, China, England, and the Dominican Republic—quickly offered humanitarian and financial assistance. President Bush's first response was to tell the audience of ABC-TV's "Good Morning, America":

"I'm not expecting much from foreign nations because we hadn't asked for it. I do expect a lot of sympathy and perhaps some will send cash dollars. But this country's going to rise up and take care of it. . . . You know, we would love help, but we're going to take care of our own business as well, and there's no doubt in my mind we'll succeed."

Cuba, which has one of the best health care and disaster response systems in the world, offered substantial medical supplies and 1,600 physicians, most of them specialists. Rejected.

Venezuela offered $1 million, in addition to oil and humanitarian supplies. Rejected.

Russia offered medical supplies, evacuation equipment, a water cleansing system, a rescue helicopter, and 60 persons specially trained in search and rescue operations. Rejected.

Germany sent a military plane carrying 15 tons of emergency provisions. The United States denied it landing rights.

Not only did the federal government reject humanitarian offers from other countries, it either rejected or ignored offers by the American people and its own governmental agencies.

Before the storm hit, Amtrak offered trains to evacuate New Orleans. Ignored.

The Forest Service, shortly after Katrina came ashore, offered water-tanker aircraft to fight the fires. Ignored.

The Coast Guard, which would fly more than 20,000 rescue operations, offered 1,000 gallons of diesel fuel to Jefferson Parrish. The federal government refused to allow delivery.

The captain of an amphibious assault ship off the Gulf Coast offered to send her sailors onto land to help the people, have her helicopters assist in rescue operations, provide as much as 100,000 gallons of drinkable water a day, and open her ship's operating rooms to provide medical assistance and 600 beds for the relief effort. The federal government ignored and then delayed her offer.

During the first week of the disaster, the federal government had ordered the Red Cross and Salvation Army not to go into the New Orleans disaster zone, falsely citing a lack of adequate security. Gov. Bill Richardson of New Mexico offered 400 National Guard soldiers the day the hurricane hit; however, they weren't sent for four more days because of what Richardson called "federal paperwork" that the Pentagon insisted had to first be completed.

Chicago offered firefighters, police, health workers, sanitation workers, a mobile health clinic, trucks, boats, and cars. Rejected.

The Florida Airboat Association offered to send in 300 fully equipped boats with trained pilots. Rejected.

About 75 companies volunteered to use their own corporate aircraft to ferry supplies into smaller local and regional airports. When the federal government ignored the offer, the companies flew in more than 130,000 pounds of food and critical supplies, making determinations without federal assistance or appreciation of where the needs were the greatest.

Hundreds of companies tried to provide several million gallons of drinking water and ice for the evacuees. The federal government either blocked their delivery or routed them on a circuitous path throughout the South, and never allowed them to unload their cargoes. Members of the International Bottled Water Association did provide 10 million bottles of fresh water for evacuees, but received no assistance from the federal government, which refused to return several phone calls.

A national corporation offered free telecommunications equipment but the federal government rejected it, according to Ern Blackwelder of the Business Executives for National Security. Blackwelder told the Atlanta Journal–Constitution that the government later contracted with the same company and paid for equipment that had previously been offered at no charge.

About a week after Katrina hit, the U.S. began accepting humanitarian aid, but only from countries it determined were its allies.

Make no mistake about it, the leaders of Myanmar are dictators who trample human rights, have led their nation into an extended economic crisis, and are interested only in keeping their own power. Almost a month after Nargis hit the Irrawaddy Delta, the junta is now finally allowing foreign aid, but not from the United States.

But also make no mistake about this. The United States under its current administration will continue to refuse humanitarian aid and personnel from Cuba, Venezuela, and any other country that doesn't agree with the Bush–Cheney politics.

[Walter Brasch is professor of journalism at Bloomsburg University and president of the Pennsylvania Press Club. He is the author of the critically-acclaimed 'Unacceptable': The Federal Response to Hurricane Katrina (January 2006) and Sinking the Ship of State: The Presidency of George W. Bush (November 2007), both available through amazon.com, borders.com, and other bookstores. You may contact Brasch at brasch@bloomu.edu or through his website at: www.walterbrasch.com. Rosemary R. Brasch assisted on this column]

Posted by Walter Brasch at June 2, 2008 12:58 AM | Guest Writings | Technorati links |

bush offered help knowing he would be refused & then he could finally point to a govt. that was even worse than his own.

He was hoping it would make him look just a little less INCOMPETENT & cold hearted.

Posted by: Bush_MUST_Go at June 3, 2008 08:13 AM

"Make no mistake about it, the leaders of USA are dictators who trample human rights, have led their nation into an extended economic crisis, and are interested only in keeping their own power." Is as much correct as the phrase oncerning Myanmar: a Democracy were the mainstreamp ress is so faulty that it only repeats Official's talking points so that more than 80% of the country believes that flat out lies are the truth, then you can hardly call it a working democracy...

Posted by: Johny europe at June 3, 2008 08:32 AM

The Bush Administration isn't like Myanmar. Think about it:

Secret prisons, show trials, torture. Who does that remind you of? Stalin!

The Bushies are Stalinists.

Posted by: Publicus at June 3, 2008 09:35 AM

great article and an intelligent enjoyable website. i noticed the ad for strangers almanac by ryan adams. i wonder how many of the 54 million fools who voted for w..........twice would understand the words to "houses on the hill"? probably absolutely zero. i enjoyed the pictures of washington and the columbia valley. i have been stuck here in bush country (unfortunately) in east tennessee trying to convince the redneck crowd not to support w (who'd they vote for a third time given that choice) or huckabee (can you believe it) or john w. mcsame. it is a very tough uphill battle. intelligence doesn't count for much around here. that's why i have been thinking about visiting your fine part of the country. please post more pictures and keep up the good work. thank you.

Posted by: mr bigstuff at June 3, 2008 11:31 AM

Of course Bush refused all that aid. His regime's intent was to see NOLA decimated, because it was a predominantly Democratic voting region, where the minorities were, or nearly were, the majority. This was an attempt by Republicans to orchestrate ethnic cleansing utilizing a natural disaster as cover. It was also a chance to practice the imposition of federal rule/effective martial law over civilian government. The harm inflicted was entirely intentional and is still ongoing. There is no qualitative difference between the thugs in charge of Myinmar and the thugs in charge of "our" government. None that I can see.

Posted by: Paul at June 3, 2008 12:29 PM

The overriding purpose of the Bush administration, the most corrupt administration in American history, is to profit off the misfortune and misery of other people.

So, of course, Bush rejected all this aid offered by other nations after Hurricane Katrina, because accepting this "unconditional" aid would cut into the profits of the crony Republican corporations who were lining up to get no-bid contracts to rebuild the Gulf Coast area after Katrina. How would these crony Republican companies be able to mark things up for a hefty profit margin (for themselves) if "free" supplies and even personnel were flooding into the devastated hurricane areas?

The Republican Party stopped being Christian a long, long time ago, but Bush and Cheney have definitely been the final nail in the Republican coffin, because these two bozos have exhibited the true, anti-Christian character of the Republican Party, with money being the only thing that is worshiped by Bush, Cheney and today's Republicans.

Their true attitude: screw our nation. Screw the little people. Screw the victims of natural disasters.

So, I agree, there are clear and present similarities between the Bush administration and the warmongering thugs who rule Myanmar.

Posted by: The Oracle at June 3, 2008 01:42 PM

OK, so Mynamar acted toward us pretty much like we acted toward other countries who tried to help New Orleans.

Um. Does this make Bush a petty tyrant? Well, actually a lot of his other acts do that quite well.

Posted by: Scorpio at June 3, 2008 03:46 PM

Johnny Europe Wrote

The Bush Administration isn't like Myanmar. Think about it:

Secret prisons, show trials, torture. Who does that remind you of? Stalin!

The Bushies are Stalinists.


What about Guantonamo Bay? Show trials and torture are the rule there. The Army judge who dismissed the charges for some of the prisoners has now been removed. The US is definetly losing its shine as a beacon in the wolrd

Posted by: Rick at June 4, 2008 07:10 AM

Revolution Is The Only Solution,Somebody Get A Rope.

Posted by: Insaneredneck at June 6, 2008 07:21 AM

Comparing Bush, Cheney, and fellow conspirators to any country is impossible. They have no conscience, morales, or empathy for their fellow human beings, and Hitler is long gone. It is extremely frightening to be an American, never would I have imagined that our Government could be taken over so easily by "absolute" corruption, and so many Americans misled. This is no longer a "democracy", the voices of us who questioned the "voter fraud" of 2000, and have distrusted everything since were silenced by a "dictatorship" hell bent on squeezing every last cent out of this country by any means necessary. They are the true "axis of evil".

Posted by: Debbie at June 7, 2008 07:36 AM

Good article. I remember reading about Canadian rescue/disaster teams waiting on airport tarmac in BC for permission to land in the US. They were ready to go within hours and we turned them down. And Secretary of State Rice was on vacation in NYC, going to Broadway shows and shopping for shoes, and later claimed she'd have no role in such a situation. The lot of them can take Long walks off Short piers.

Posted by: PurpleGirl at June 7, 2008 04:59 PM